“The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.”
– John 1:5

    “I have never told anyone. It happened when I was ten. Do you understand that this has destroyed my entire life? I can’t hide it anymore. I need to heal.” This broken grandmother of nine sat across the table from me with her head in her hands. She sobbed quietly as the tears that held her captive for over 60 years were finally released. She was ready to speak the truth about the unspeakable horror she endured at the hands of her father, who was a pastor, when she was merely a child. She was finally ready to surrender the dark secret she had vowed never to speak of. Unfortunately, this story is not unusual, women have kept their sexual assault stories hidden since the beginning of time. The darkness of sexual abuse and exploitation has crept into the church, causing pain and destruction within the Body of Christ. The topic of sexual abuse and exploitation is rejected by many faith-based communities, including churches, seminaries, and schools.

“An overwhelming majority of the pastors surveyed (75%) underestimate the level of violence experienced within their congregations. Additionally, two out of three (66%) pastors speak once a year or less about the issue — and when they do speak out, the poll shows they may be providing support that does more harm than good.”

Many victims of sexual abuse, whether they were abused in the church or somewhere else, seek spiritual guidance and support from the Body of Christ. In many cases, when a victim or family member approaches the church for help, they are referred out of the church back to secular county agencies such as law enforcement, a sexual assault center, or a medical facility. Victims seek help from the church because sexual assault attacks the very soul of a person, leaving them to question who they are and who God is. We know as the fellowship of believers that Christ alone holds the healing power to set abuse victims free. John 8:36 tells us, “So if the Son sets you free, you will be made free indeed.” So why are we so quick to refer victims out into the world to seek secular answers to their deeply spiritual questions, answers that reject the healing power of Christ? Many church leaders say simply that they are not trained or equipped. Referring people facing sexual abuse and exploitation issues to another expert may seem easier because their leadership and staff are not equipped to handle the complex nature of a sexual assault disclosure within their faith community.

And though 81% of pastors said they would take appropriate action to reduce sexual and domestic violence if they had the training and resources to do so, the “Broken Silence” report generated from this research highlights–at best–a significant blind spot within our churches in recognizing, responding to, and preventing gender-based sexual violence.

“More pastors say they are addressing sexual and domestic violence from the pulpit. Still, half say they lack training in how to address sexual and domestic violence.”

In an article about the biblical response of clergy towards victims, Eric Bruns says, “Clergy members are one of several potential candidates for initial disclosure, as well as prominent sources of potential support. However, despite the potential role of clergy in supporting community members who have been victimized, there is a perception that many clergy members are not well-trained or adequately supported to serve as responders.” The church has a profound role in helping victims heal by responding with the love of Christ. 1 Peter 2:9 says, “But you are a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, God’s special possession, that you may declare the praises of him who called you out of darkness into his wonderful light.” From data published in a Barna study of over 400 senior church leaders across all Protestant denominations, Daniel Weiss says, “We need to understand how our church structures, traditions, and culture combine to create systemic problems that facilitate ongoing abuse. They have no framework or context for dealing with sex in their churches.”

  A majority of Pastors agree that awareness, training, and a biblical response to sexual issues is a blind spot in most churches. Many churches hope they will never have to face a sexual abuse or exploitation case in their church or organization and panic when they do. It is not uncommon for a church to never have discussed how to respond biblically to a sexual abuse disclosure from a congregant. Many churches ignore the issue until they are forced to deal with it in the middle of a crisis. This can cause harm to the entire church body and inflict secondary harm upon the reporting victim. Even more so if the perpetrator is also a part of the church. Basyle Tchividjian says, “When the victim and the alleged offender are part of the same faith community, the initial response by the institution is often to try and figure out an equitable way to address the matter without “offending” either party. Such an approach will always fail. Church leaders believe that their ultimate responsibility is to protect and care for the most vulnerable members of their church. Jesus was always on the side of the vulnerable and the wounded.” We need to train and equip pastors and other church leaders to fulfill their calling in caring for the sexually abused.

Another complex component of this issue for the church is the perceived need for humans to place blame for hidden sexual sin. Disclosures are complicated. When a victim comes forward and identifies actual names, faces, places, and situations are defined, human nature tempts us to place blame either on the victim or the perpetrator. As soon as blame shifting occurs, the conversation stops because the reaction becomes more about fixing the problem than ministering to the people involved. When church leadership has hidden sexual sin within its ranks in the form of adultery or pornography use, the issue is further complicated. The Westminster Catechism addresses the issue of sexual abuse and exploitation in the church this way, “Sexual desire is perverted and corrupted by sinful men, we must respond biblically because the Bible itself does so.” Sexual sin is often hidden in plain sight in our churches, and guilty leaders do not want to open the door to conversations about sexual integrity for fear of being exposed themselves.

Sexual abuse expert Diane Langburg says, “Anyone in a position of power within the body of Christ who abuses a lamb or hides the abuse done to the one the Good Shepherd knows and calls by name has profaned the name of our God.” Intentional and predetermined biblical responses to both victims and perpetrators can help a congregation rocked by sexual abuse heal. This is why shining light on this issue is so critical to the health and well-being of our church communities.

The church can do better.

The Bible is clear about how we are to come alongside hurting people who are impacted by sexual sin. The church has a clear biblical mandate to respond with truth, love, and guidance through the Holy Spirit. 1 John 1:5-7 urges, “This is the message we have heard from him and proclaim to you, that God is light, and in him is no darkness at all. If we say we have fellowship with him while we walk in darkness, we lie and do not practice the truth. But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin.”

Illuminate is a verb that means to make something visible or bright by shining light on it, light up, to help clarify or explain. Illuminating this issue of sexual abuse and exploitation can help bring hope and healing to the church. Equipping and training church leaders to minister to their flock according to biblical standards with the love of Christ, no matter how messy the situation gets, is crucial. We cannot keep turning people away from the church and referring them to the world for help. If they come to the church looking for Christ and healing, it is our responsibility as Christian leaders to help them find a relationship with Jesus Christ so they can experience salvation, true freedom, hope, and healing at the foot of the cross. This quote from Pastor Jack Hayford in his book Fatal Attractions summarizes this brilliantly.

“Our God is a glorious redeemer, fully able to recover and repair even the most damaged soul. He is ever ready to bring us wholeness in Jesus Christ and thereby lay a solid foundation for the future. With that, walls of defense may be built, enabling us to discern and defend ourselves from the thieving tactics of our ferocious enemies – our weak selves and our strong adversary. There is no bondage He cannot untangle, no hurt He cannot heal. For those who long to be loved but have never known how, God’s Holy Spirit not only can bring a sense of cleansing forgiveness through Jesus’ Cross, but also will restore and rebuild the shattered temple of your soul and make it a glorious place for God’s love to “Any church leader who feeds themselves rather than feeding the sheep is a counterfeit shepherd.”

By raising awareness and equipping church leaders, we can begin to transform faith communities with new conversations focused on bringing hope and healing to sexual abuse victims and perpetrators. This can lead to embracing biblical best practices to minister to those impacted.

Blogs from Illuminatetheissue.org exist to shine a light on the issue of sexual abuse and exploitation in faith communities. Illuminate seeks to raise awareness and equip leaders to transform the culture in Christian churches, seminaries, schools, and community organizations by raising awareness and helping church leaders minister to victims, perpetrators, and those closest to them from a Christ-centered and Biblical framework of sexual discipleship.

Trish Propson, MAPC, MACM, Certified Biblical Counselor, and Licensed Chaplain, serves as the Director of Illuminatetheissue.org. Trish uses her own redemption story from sexual abuse and exploitation to start new conversations exposing the impact of sexual abuse and exploitation in Christian communities. For more information or to book a training, workshop, or retreat, please email: trish@illuminatetheissue.org.

 

Bibliography
Bruns, Eric. “Clergy Members as Responders to Victims of Sexual Abuse and Assault.” Journal of Religion & Spirituality in Social Work, vol. 24, no. 3, 22 Sept. 2005, pp. 3–19, https://doi.org/10.1300/j377v24n03_02. Accessed 5 Apr. 2020.
Hayford, Jack. Fatal Attractions: Why Sex Sins Are Worse Than Others ( Ventura, CA: Gospel Light/Regal Books, 2004.
Langburg, Diane. “Abuse of Power Comes as no Surprise.” Not in our church. Last Modified 2024. https://www.notinourchurch.com/statistics.html Not in our Church. “Abuse of power comes as no surprise.” Privacy and Terms. Last modified 2024.
https://www.notinourchurch.com/statistics.html
Tchividjian, Basyle J. “Responding with Excellence to an Allegation of Sexual Abuse
Within the Church.” Currents in Theology and Mission, 45 no.3 (2018). https://currentsjournal.org/index.php/currents/issue/view/53.
Weiss, Daniel. “Sexuality and the Church in America.” Brushfires Foundation and The True North Freedom Project, (2018). www.brushfiresfoundation.org/integrity.
“The Westminster Shorter Catechism.” Grand Rapids, MI: Christian Classics Ethereal Library, 2004.